The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria

Verified by N49

The overall exp was not too good, service was poor, had to ask for same thing multiple times, water served was not clean and every time glass was untidy each time. Pizza was ok on taste not that good but service was poor. Patio is good, interiors are mediocre and very closely placed.
Had to ask for chilly flakes which never came to the table, still gave the tip to the server but no thank you, acknowledgement. Not recommended if you are looking for a pleasing experience and ambience.
Can try other cafes, multiple available on the street with better services

Such a gem to eat at! My fiancé and I absolutely love this place! The margarita pizza and mozzarella sticks are always a hit for us here. The donuts are always fresh and fluffy too! Would definitely recommend it if you’re visiting Toronto.

Visited after reading the positive online reviews. It's very good pizza compared to "hot and ready" fast food chains, but not pizza Elysium. It's definitely above average, that's it. Friendly staff, quaint atmosphere, decent pizza. Oh btw, they make homemade donuts. Didn't try them but they looked yummy.

Our 41st anniversary weekend in Toronto. Fourth Man on Fire was highly recommended for great pizza. I called at 630pm to see if we needed a reservation. No you don’t we have tables available, I said where we were staying and we’d Uber over right away. 20 minutes later we arrive and they told they had no pizza dough for eat in and the restaurant was closing. We could get take out. You have dough for take out but not eat in? We left and went to a fabulous Italian restaurant down the street.

I had an amazing experience at The Fourth Man in the Fire Pizzeria! The food was absolutely delicious from start to finish.

Really impressed with this place! Started with the mozzarella sticks—crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside, just perfect. I had a half-and-half pizza (pepperoni & mushrooms on one side, mushrooms & black olives on the other), and both were packed with flavor. The crust was light and delicious, and the toppings were fresh and generous.

Finished off with an apple fritter donut and a cookies & cream donut—both were sweet, soft, and super satisfying. Everything was on point. Definitely a 5/5 experience!

I’d heard about Fourth Man in the Fire for years—especially when Ryan Reynolds name-dropped it while talking about his Toronto roots. Naturally, it shot to the top of my “must-try” list.

Finally made the trip, and I have to say, the pizza dough lives up to the hype. Thin, crispy, with just the right chew—it’s the kind of base that holds its own. I ordered the Margherita, my usual benchmark for any new pizza spot. While I wasn’t blown away by the toppings, the dough definitely carried the show.

The space has that classic, no-fuss vibe, and service was quick. If you're into solid, New York-style slices and value a good crust, it’s absolutely worth checking out.

They just have it all!!! Before you even sit down, you’re greeted with a smile and a wave of kindness from all members of the team. We had the caesar salad and mozzarella sticks to start - which both hit the spot. The pizza was flavourful, fresh and crust was perfect crispness. On the car ride home after leaving the restaurant, my heart and belly were so happily full. Can’t wait to come back again already

First time visiting this place, and it turned out to be a great spot to enjoy pizza with a group of friends. The atmosphere was welcoming, and the food was delicious. The pizza had a perfect balance of flavors, with fresh ingredients and a crispy crust. Definitely a place worth coming back to!

A great little pizza joint! Definitely top three in Toronto. Service was excellent and attentive. Pizza was delicious - truly enjoyed being able to get a half and half. The donuts are a great treat after eating the amazing pie!

Not sure why there are so many glowing reviews of this place. Frankly, I’m skeptical that they’re real.

The food is decent. We had the BBQ chicken pizza, which had barely any chicken on it and was too sweet. The crust was okay. The Caesar salad was good, but didn’t have actual Caesar dressing. It was some kind of vinaigrette.

The service was just okay. No idea why other reviews called this place welcoming. It felt very awkward asking for a table, then the server explained that you have to place your order using your phone (???). So the server doesn’t take any orders. Just runs your food to the table.

To order on your phone, they ask for a name, an email, AND a phone number. None of which are necessary and kind of feels like a scam tbh.

The decor is pretty cute, and the bathroom was surprisingly really clean. The dining are was really cold, though. A bunch of people were wearing winter jackets inside. Definitely not worth going back.

Hands down, one of the best pizza spots ever! I had it ones at an event and couldn’t stop thinking about the pizza. I mission to find where the host got it from and was delighted when I was able to go in person. The ingredients are top-notch—fresh, high-quality, and perfectly balanced. Unlike other places, I don’t feel tired or bloated afterward. It’s light, flavorful, and absolutely delicious! The service is also amazing, staff are very friendly and courteous. One of the servers offered us donuts as a thank you. We are more than happy with everything and will visit again soon.

Had a lunch here a few weeks ago. Staff very welcoming. I really enjoyed our pizza. Nice undercarriage with good crispness. The pizza sauce, dough, etc had a very nice lightness (I.e. not greasy), which was very refreshing compared to the very heavy pizza that are out there. Been thinking of that pizza since, we’ll probably swing by in the future and if we lived near, probably more often!

If you're looking for the ultimate combination of pizza and donuts, this is the spot! From the moment I walked in, the customer service was outstanding. The staff were friendly, attentive, and went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect.

Now, onto the food—wow! The pizza was nothing short of amazing: perfectly crisp crust, flavorful sauce, and toppings that tasted fresh and high-quality. And just when I thought it couldn't get better, I tried the donuts. They were soft, fresh, and melted in my mouth—truly the perfect sweet treat to follow up the savory goodness.

This place nailed it on all fronts: food, service, and atmosphere. I can’t recommend it enough! Whether you're craving pizza, donuts, or both, you’ll leave here happy and full.

I want to start off by saying Thank You.

We've been so excited to celebrate our 9th wedding anniversary when plans changed suddenly. Our vacation became a staycation.

We've had and love Elijah's Automatic and omgoodness yes the donuts!!! So we decided to have pizza & Pjs party.

Our door dasher just disappeared....door dash resolved the issue but you guys recreated everything again for us with so much love!!!!

Thank you thank you thank you!!!!

The level care, love, professionalism and custom care was incredible.

Thank you for making our 9th Anniversary Dinner - hehe Pizza & Pj's 🥳🍕

food we ate: meatball sub, Italian sub, french press coffee, sour cream glazed donut, and maple donut (not pictured) - all so delicious! we will be back again for sure. Staff were all super friendly too.

Jut we walk around and we see the restaurant just get open and we get in , when we get in the smell make us instantly to stay and try , location good, restaurant very clean, spotless, environment very welcoming and friendliness. We start we amazing donuts 🍩 from HARRY and HEELS California Donuts - they are amazing still know I fell the flavour from my donuts, choice are a lot just try and you don’t regret anything.
After we had amazing chat leader of restaurant what she share with us amazing story about how they get in, how they create all the delicious donuts and the amazing delicious pizza, she was amazing and we thank you for sharing with us the story behind’s the success. The pizza come to the table smells delicious, looks amazing attractive, and it was just Margaritas but was super mega delicious 🤤 the pizza brings me back to my childhood life in Napoli when I eat pizza 🍕 the same taste, not to soft, juicy, delicious and delicate. Yes the pizza is the best what I eat in Toronto you need just to try definitely we will be back and thank you for doings amazing work. The service was perfect.

I was doing a little pizza crawl across Toronto with a friend and The Fourth Man in the Fire was our second stop! I've heard good things about this spot and this was my first time stopping by.

The staff were very nice and even though we bought a slice to-go, we were able to grab a seat to eat in their dining room. However, it was a weekday afternoon so not that busy.

What we got:
- Margherita Slice + Donut + Drink Combo

Final Thoughts:
Their slices are quite large, I asked before purchasing and I believe they said one slice is 1/5 of a full pizza!

A slice on its own runs about $7 and a donut alone ranges from $4-5, but you can get a combo with both and a drink for $11.29 total.

The Margherita slice was on the cheesier side which I liked and the donut was a good sweet treat though a little too sweet for my taste. Considering the cost, this wouldn't be my first pick for a quick slice but I'd stop in again.

One of my favourite pizza places! We got the sausage and onion pizza with garlic and hot honey dips and they tasted superb. Their donuts don’t lack either; so soft and sweet! Amazing staff and always accommodating especially Socrates. I recommend this place. Come with friends!

This pizza was a treat! The crust was spot-on, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. The mushrooms and red peppers gave it a nice earthy taste, while the pineapple added a sweet twist also the staff was really friendly and kind amazing atmosphere. I’ll definitely order from here again!

This place is great. Their pizzas are the tastiest we had in Toronto, and the service is really friendly. Would happily return!

We have either walked by this location or only visited for the donuts but we finally decided to check out the Pizza. We made reservations by calling into the restaurant. Glad we did as the place got busy quick!

The pizza itself was great and really big, we also tried the garlic sticks. Both didn’t disappoint and we had about half the pizza to take home. Also had to get a donut for take out, they are a must try!

Definitely worth checking out if you haven’t, and we will definitely go back!

A truly amazing experience at this pizzeria.🍕

A true pizza connoisseur will taste and feel the aged dough, and fresh ingredients and subtle nuances of flavour. 😋👌

We ordered the Classic Margherita and Sausage and Onion.

The staff is super friendly and warm.

Simran is a gem. 💎

Best regards.